If you’re like me, you know Erich von Stroheim best as Max Von Mayerling, the butler (and first husband) of aging silent movie star Norma Desmond (Gloria Swanson) in the classic 1950 noir Sunset Blvd.
But there was so much more to von Stroheim than Max.
While writing about von Stroheim for the soon-to-be-released Sunset Blvd. edition of The Dark Pages film noir newsletter, I became utterly obsessed with this actor/director. And, as luck would have it, I had the opportunity to view the Flicker Alley 4K restoration of one of his first directorial efforts, Foolish Wives (1922), a slient film that – the opening credits unabashedly inform us – was “conceived and realized in its entirety by Erich von Stroheim, based on his novel, Foolish Wives.”
In a nutshell, the film centers on exiled “Russian aristocrats” Count Sergius Karamzin (von Stroheim), his cousins, Princess Olga (Maude George) and Princess Vera (Mae Busch), who live in a rented villa in Monaco and finance their lavish existence by passing counterfeit bills. Sergius also preys on wealthy women who visit nearby Monte Carlo, and Foolish Wives shows us the females who fall under his spell, including the family’s maid, Maruschka (Dale Fuller), and Helen Hughes (Miss DuPont), the wife of the U.S. Special Envoy to Monaco. Sergius is a cad of the first degree – he’s not only carrying on with these women, but he also has eyes on the “half-witted” daughter of the counterfeiter with whom he’s in cahoots, and there is some question – given their intimate actions – whether Olga and Vera are actually his cousins (and if they are, they appear to be “kissing” cousins, if you know what I mean. And I think you do.).
The film is captivating in its depiction of the sly manner in which Sergius ingratiates himself into the life of Helen Hughes, arranging to take boat ride with her, sending her flowers – and, ironically, offering to be her “protector” against charlatans who would be after her money. (Amusingly, when Sergius first meets Helen, she is sitting on a terrace reading a book. The book is Foolish Wives by Erich von Stroheim!)
Numerous scenes featuring von Stroheim are standouts. In one, Sergius invites Helen to accompany him on a walk, but the two get caught in a severe storm and they take refuge in a shack owned by an old woman. While Helen changes into dry clothes, Sergius respectfully leaves the room, but he spies on her in the reflection of his mirror. (Incidentally, this shot – with the mirror showing half of Segius’s leering face and half of Helen’s bare back – is quite striking and one of the most memorable of the film.)
In another scene, Sergius pulls out all the stops in an effort to separate Helen from a wad of cash that she recently won in a casino. He spins some sort of obscure tale about a debt of honor that must be paid with money or with blood, telling her, “I have given all to my country – and now that I need, I have not. I place my life in your hands.” (In the words of Virginia Grey in The Women [1939], holy mackerel, what a line!) He turns to face the wall in shame but manages to peek behind him to gauge Helen’s reaction. When he sees that Helen is withdrawing her money from her purse, he allows himself a satisfied smirk before fixing his face into its mask of contrition again.
And Sergius uses more subterfuge with the family maid, Maruschka, who he has promised to marry (possibly, although it’s not explicitly stated, because he has gotten her pregnant). He blames the postponed nuptials on his “unsettled estates” in Russia, but when he learns that Maruschka has socked away a tidy sum during her 20 years of service, he puts on a show worthy of Broadway. After soaking his nails in water (as part of a manicure he’d been giving himself), Sergius hides his face with his hands, lightly flicking the water from his fingers to give the impression of tears falling to the tablecloth. When Maruschka sees this, she immediately gives him all of her savings (even the coins!), and Sergius laughs with diabolical glee when her back is turned. Sergius is completely unredeemable, as he demonstrates throughout the film, and his vile behavior leads to a comeuppance at the end that is as satisfying as it is gruesome.

With its lavish sets, costumes, and meticulous attention to detail (including von Stroheim’s insistence on real caviar and champagne), Foolish Wives was known as the “first million-dollar movie” – a fact that I learned from one of the bonus features included with the Flicker Alley set. These include an excerpt from Pathe’s Screen Snapshots series, featuring rare on-set footage from the film; a documentary short about the historical and thematic importance of the film’s locations; a documentary on the making of the film, presented by Dave Kehr, film curator for New York’s Museum of Modern Art (MoMA); and a featurette focusing on the film’s painstaking restoration. The set is a dual format Blu-ray/DVD edition and is accompanied by a new orchestral score composed and conducted by Timothy Brock (originally commissioned for the 2020 San Francisco Silent Film Festival). Also included with the set is a beautifully illustrated 24-page booklet that offers a new essay by James Layton, Manager, Celeste Bartos Film Preservation Center at The Museum of Modern Art, entitled “Searching for Foolish Wives: The Decades-Long Effort to Reconstruct Erich von Stroheim’s Masterpiece,” and excerpts from an examination of the film by critic and author David Thomson. It makes for a first-rate package that has served to fuel my fascination with von Stroheim and pique my interest in seeing more of his work.
Other stuff:
Rudolph Christians, who played Ambassador Hughes, died of pneumonia in the middle of the production; he was 52 years old. His part was completed by another actor, Robert Edeson, whose scenes were shot from the back.
A pivotal role was served up by the maid, Maruschka, portrayed by Dale Fuller. Her career was primarily in the silent era, including other von Stroheim productions such as Greed (1924) and The Merry Widow (1925), but she also appeared in a handful of talking films. These include the film that I best know her from – The Office Wife (1930) – along with Twentieth Century (1934), and her last film, The Tale of Two Cities (1935).
There is a particular scene in the film that struck me as a forerunner of the film noir era. In it, Sergius goes to the home of the counterfeiter, Cesare Ventucci (Cesare Gravina), who lives with his daughter, Marietta (Malvina Polo). On two separate occasions, the men enter the bedroom of Marietta, who is asleep. The blinds of her window are open, casting a noir-like depiction of light and shadow, complete with dust motes floating in the air. It makes one wonder when the first window blind shadows appeared in film noir – and whether the cinematographer was a fan of von Stroheim.
My thanks to Flicker Alley for providing a review copy of this Blu-ray/DVD set. It can be purchased at the Flicker Alley website or through Amazon and other online retailers.































































































































































