I’m Just One Punch Away: The Set-Up

The Set-Up takes place in real-time, during a single night at the Paradise City boxing arena.

One of the films that I included on my recent list of Top 10 films noirs was The Set-Up, starring Robert Ryan and Audrey Totter. To me, both Ryan and Totter are quintessential noir performers – Ryan was unforgettable in Crossfire (1947), Clash By Night (1952), and Odds Against Tomorrow (1959), while Totter was simply outstanding in The Unsuspected (1947) and Tension (1950). But I think they both give their best work in 1949’s The Set-Up. (Watch your step – spoilers ahead!)

The Set-Up offers a simple story, particularly by the standards of the film noir era, which was known to present plots so complex that you sometimes give up trying to figure out who was done in by whom. This film, conversely, can be summed up in one sentence – it’s about an aging boxer trying to win a fight, against all odds. I believe that it is the simplicity of The Set-Up’s plot that allows the film to illustrate such rich and varied characters.

An aging boxer with more losses than wins, Stoker Thompson (Robert Ryan) was nothing if not determined.

At the heart of the film are the boxer, Bill “Stoker” Thompson (Ryan) and his wife, Julie (Totter). Stoker is wise and experienced, hardened and cynical – he’s been around the block, he’s seen it all. He’s no champion; perhaps in his heyday, he came close, but now he loses far more bouts than he wins. But on the single night depicted in the film, Stoker is confident that he can emerge the victor.

Julie, however, is not so certain. She, too, has seen it all – she’s seen her husband on the canvas more times than she can remember, and she’s had it. Refusing to attend the night’s bout, Julie tells Stoker, “It ain’t I want to hurt you, but what kind of life is this? How many more beatings do you have to take?”

The end of Stoker’s career.

The cast is also enhanced by the performances of George Tobias (Tiny) and Percy Helton (Red). Tobias and Helton play Stoker’s manager and trainer, respectively, and sell him out to a local gangster with the odd moniker of Little Boy (Alan Baxter), who shells out a grand total of fifty bucks to guarantee that Stoker will take a fall. Trouble is, Tiny and Red neglect to inform Stoker about this deal until the third round – after it becomes obvious that he is going to win. Refusing to take a dive, Stoker emerges the victor, but in the alley behind the boxing arena, he is beaten by Little Boy’s henchmen, who break his hand, effectively ending his boxing career forever.

One of the crowd members who added to the richness of the film, this fella was as interested in his hot dog as the boxing match.

One of my favorite things about The Set-Up is the small roles, including the depiction of the members of the crowd viewing the fight – there is a blind man who has every move explained to him by his companion; a corpulent fellow who sits eating popcorn and an assortment of other snacks like he’s a kid at the circus; a woman who claims to be squeamish but who watches the matches in a frenzy of excitement and is once heard shrieking, “Quit stalling! Let’s have some action!” Other small, but effective, parts go to the boxers in the other bouts – one is a nervous youngster preparing for his first fight, another is a gentle sort who reads the Bible before entering the ring, and yet another is a punchy old-timer who is knocked unconscious during his unsuccessful bout. Their appearances are brief, but unforgettable, and serve to add to the film’s depth.

From start to finish, this Robert Wise-directed picture – which is seen in real-time – is riveting. If you haven’t seen it, see it. And if you’ve seen it, see it again.

You only owe it to yourself.

~ by shadowsandsatin on September 6, 2011.

7 Responses to “I’m Just One Punch Away: The Set-Up”

  1. Yeah, I really like that movie, too. What makes this film extra-special is that it offered a good part for a black actor (James Edwards), which wasn’t quite common in those pre-Sidney-Poitier days. Also, this movie plays in real time and is a perfect example of effective storytelling in less than 75 minutes, something that I often really miss in modern cinema.
    Again, thaks for the nice artice, Karen.

  2. […] and an amazing film noir and yet I can never remember the name of the movie . Thanks for Karen at Shadows and Satin for the reminder and this great […]

  3. […] This is my favorite Robert Ryan movie and one of my best-loved noirs. (I might add, Ryan counted it among his favorites as well.) In it, Ryan plays Stoker Thompson, an aging boxer who was, according to one description, “one punch away from being punch-drunk.” The film’s first-rate cast includes the always-great Audrey Totter, George Tobias, Wallace Ford, and Percy Helton. (You can read more about my take on this movie here.) […]

  4. A great noir which thematically hits the mark as well. Always been fascinated by the futility of the protagonist trying to get out from under – and often almost succeeding. Someone who has had all the hard knocks and just wants out. That faint glimmer of hope that is then extinguished. There is a tragic element to it but that’s too simple in the world of noir – because fate is something you cannot gamble with or cheat. Thanks for a great article. (Going to share this!) Regards!

    • Thank you so much for your kind words — and for sharing my post! You are so right about The Set-Up being great. It’s such a simple story, but so well illustrated. It’s absolutely fascinating, not just for the core story about Stoker, but so many other characters as well.

  5. […] Baby Face (1933), Dinner at Eight (1933), Out of the Past (1947), They Live By Night (1948), The Set-Up (1949), and Wicked Woman (1954). But aside from these gems, I was still left with a veritable […]

  6. […] in real-time, The Set-Up is a showcase for the considerable talents of Robert Ryan, who plays a boxer who’s not exactly in […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: